Answers & stories

Neighborhood Guides

What are the neighborhoods in Middleton, Idaho, and what do homes cost in each?

Middleton homes sold at a $523,500 median over the last 12 months, but the price depends a lot on which side of town you buy. The South and East sides sold around $423K to $443K, Old Town about $448K, the West Highlands area $555K and the north side $699K, while acreage up Lansing Ln hit a $1.18 million median.

Middleton Neighborhood Guide cover showing neighborhood median prices
Middleton Neighborhood Guide cover showing neighborhood median prices

I went through every Middleton home that sold in the last 12 months, 552 sales in all, plus everything for sale today, and broke it down area by area. Here's what I found, in plain English.

The big picture: the median sold price was $523,500, or about $256 per square foot. Homes sold in a median of 42 days at 98.3% of their original asking price, and about six in ten sellers paid toward the buyer's closing costs, a median of $10,200. Just over half the homes sold were brand new, at a $544,000 median versus $510,000 for resales. Two in three were single level, and 15% sat on an acre or more. Middleton is now about 15,110 people, up 60% since 2020.

Old Town & Central ($448K median, 58 sales). Main Street and Middleton Rd, with 1930s to 90s homes and no HOA, a short walk to downtown. This is where you'll find Middleton's most affordable homes: Canyon Villa sold at a $330K median, Middleton Place $340K, Johnson Park $350K and Old Town Middleton itself $352K. New homes are going in here too, at The Mill at Middleton (Generation Homes NW, $642K median) and Hidden Mill (White Peak Homes, $579K). Kennedy Meadows' big 2005 to 2006 homes sold around $578K.

South, toward the Boise River ($423K median, 32 sales). Middleton Lakes, with ponds and paths near the river, sold at a $408K median, and newer Sawtooth Lakes at $390K. River Walk Crossing is the big exception: custom homes on half-acre lots by the river at a $1.41 million median, with a top sale of $1.85 million and 22 homes listed now from Tradewinds and Canyon Crest.

West, around West Highlands ($555K median, 186 sales). Middleton's busiest area. Toll Brothers' Meadows at West Highlands sold 100 homes at a $562K median, the most of any community in town. Richmond American's Stonehaven sold at $614K with RV parking, and Lennar's Carlton Meadows at $461K. West Highlands Ranch (Coleman and Toll homes, community pool) sold around $495K and West Highlands Estates around $580K. Nottingham Greens is the budget pick here at $370K.

North, around Meadow Park ($699K median, 58 sales). Bigger lots and semi-custom homes north of Willis Rd toward Purple Sage Rd. Hayden's new Willow Wood Estates sold at a $475K median, and Crossing at Meadow Park's big Hubble floor plans at $550K. Move up to Estates at West Highlands ($717K), half-acre lots at Valhalla Country Estates ($797K) and Black Acres Estates ($883K), or Maddyn Homes' Country Sage Ranches, acre homesites with shops at a $1.24 million median.

East, along Duff Ln ($443K median, 122 sales). This is where new homes cost the least. CBH sold 64 homes at Kestrel Estates and 35 at Waverly Park, both at a $441K median. Greenlinks sold around $421K and Falcon Valley around $430K. Hubble's Waterford sold at $520K, and RTL Homes' Crescent Lake, on a pond off Kingsbury Rd, at $642K.

Northeast, along Lansing Ln ($1.18 million median, 32 sales). Custom homes on one- to two-acre lots, many with shops and RV room, up toward the foothills. Lansing Lane Acreage, Oakley Estates and Cascade Hills all sold at a $1.18 million median, and Quail Haven at $1.23 million. Outside the named subdivisions, another 27 homes sold on an acre or more at a $920K median, and Middleton's top sale was $2.72 million on 4.2 acres.

For sale and building now: 288 homes are for sale or under contract, and 71% of them are new construction, with a median asking price of $569,945. CBH Homes (96) and Toll Brothers (83) built six in ten new homes sold last year. Kestrel Estates and Waverly Park had 65 new homes listed between them, starting around $408K, and Meadows at West Highlands has 55 listed from about $426K to $781K. Ask about builder incentives, like rate buy-downs, before you write an offer.

Every home sold in Middleton last year was assigned to Middleton High School. Elementary schools include Heights, Mill Creek and Purple Sage depending on the address.

I put all of this into a free 14-page Middleton Neighborhood Guide with photos, maps, price ranges, lot sizes and who's building in each area. Download it free at brad.livinginidaho.com/middleton-neighborhood-guide (instant PDF, no phone number needed), or text me at (208) 996-4872 and I'll send it over. Thinking of a move to Middleton, let's connect.

Your situation is probably a little different

Text me the specifics and I'll tell you straight how I'd handle it.

Thinking about selling?

What is your Star home actually worth right now?

Not an automated guess off a website. A real opinion of value from someone who has walked these subdivisions, with the comparable sales that back it up.

Text BradCall