Answers & stories

Neighborhood Guides

What are the neighborhoods in Garden City, Idaho, and what do homes cost in each?

Garden City houses and townhomes sold at a $545,000 median over the last 12 months, and where you buy makes a big difference. The Marigold & Glenwood area was the most affordable at a $432K median, the Plantation and East End areas ran from about $443K to $588K, and Lakeland ($612K) and Riverside Drive ($728K) were the priciest.

Garden City Neighborhood Guide cover showing neighborhood median prices
Garden City Neighborhood Guide cover showing neighborhood median prices

I went through every Garden City home that sold in the last 12 months, 155 sales in all, plus everything for sale today, and broke it down area by area. Townhomes are such a big part of the market here that I counted them alongside houses: 92 houses and 63 townhomes. Here's what I found, in plain English.

The big picture: the median sold price was $545,000, or about $310 per square foot. Houses sold at a $602,000 median and townhomes at $495,000. Homes sold in a median of 18 days at 99.2% of their original asking price, and about one in four sellers paid toward the buyer's closing costs, a median of $5,000. Four in ten sales were townhomes, and every brand-new home sold was a townhome: 23 of them at a $430K median, with no new detached houses at all.

East End & Live-Work-Create ($588K median, 30 sales). The east end runs from about 33rd to 45th Street between Chinden and the river. It's home to the Surel Mitchell Live-Work-Create District, the Riverside Hotel and a cluster of wineries and tasting rooms, with the Greenbelt along the water. Most sales here were townhomes, 18 of 30, from about $500K at TwoTown Parkway Station to $1.7M at Waterhouse Row ($1.50M median). Casino Beach sold four brand-new townhomes at an $851K median. The older streets of Fairview Acres had Garden City's lowest prices, a $374K median with houses from $327K. Most homes here go to Boise High.

Plantation & 50th Street ($443K median, 42 sales). The middle of town, on both sides of the river. North of the river, The Plantation ($690K median) and Savannah Greens ($463K) sit next to the Plantation Country Club golf course. South of the river, off Chinden between 50th and 53rd, new townhome rows have gone up. This was Garden City's busiest area for new homes: 19 brand-new townhomes sold, 17 of them at Mountain View Townhomes from $390K to $449K. Houses here are older and bigger, at a $760K median. Every sale went to Capital High.

Marigold & Glenwood ($432K median, 35 sales). South of the river and north of Chinden, off Glenwood, Marigold and Coffey streets. Mostly 1980s and '90s homes on smaller lots. Houses sold at a $458K median, the lowest in Garden City, and the Penny Lane and Westminster townhomes at $395K. Gated Willowbrook sold at $409K, Millstream & Marigold Park at $400K, Hazelbrook & Bentwood at $489K and Rivers Edge, near the water, at $592K. Nearly every home here was assigned to Eagle High in the West Ada School District.

Riverside Drive ($728K median, 38 sales). North of the river between Glenwood Street and Ulmer Lane, reached from State Street. Riverside Village ($722K), Meadow Creek ($685K) and gated Woods at Riverside are laid out around ponds and waterways, with larger homes on lots up to an acre. Woods at Riverside alone sold 10 homes at a $1.26M median, and Garden City's top sale was here: $2.7 million for a 6,570 sq ft home on 1.1 acres. Every home here goes to Capital High.

Lakeland & Horseshoe Bend ($612K median, 10 sales). The west end of town, south of State Street off Horseshoe Bend Road and Ulmer Lane. Lakeland Village dates from the early 2000s and sold at a $724K median; Carlton Bay is from the 2010s and sold at $597K. Only 10 homes sold here, so prices can swing. Both go to Capital High.

For sale and building now: 53 houses and townhomes are for sale or under contract, at a $599,000 median asking price, and 21% of them (11 homes) are new construction. Garden City has very little open land left, so new homes are mostly townhome rows on infill lots: Mountain View Townhomes by Boise City Building Co. from $385K to $434K, Coffey Townhomes by Cedar & Sage from $448K to $455K, Riverpath by Treasured Homes from $725K to $750K, and Casino Beach from $850K to $3.10M.

Garden City has no high school of its own. Most homes go to Capital or Boise High in the Boise School District, and the Marigold area goes to Eagle High in West Ada.

I put all of this into a free 14-page Garden City Neighborhood Guide with photos, maps, price ranges, lot sizes and who's building in each area. Download it free at brad.livinginidaho.com/garden-city-neighborhood-guide (instant PDF, no phone number needed), or text me at (208) 996-4872 and I'll send it over. Thinking of a move to Garden City, let's connect.

Your situation is probably a little different

Text me the specifics and I'll tell you straight how I'd handle it.

Thinking about selling?

What is your Star home actually worth right now?

Not an automated guess off a website. A real opinion of value from someone who has walked these subdivisions, with the comparable sales that back it up.

Text BradCall