Neighborhood Guides
What are the neighborhoods in Caldwell, Idaho, and what do homes cost in each?
Caldwell homes sold at a $424,990 median over the last 12 months, and where you buy makes a big difference. Downtown & Central was the most affordable area at a $350K median, the newer east and south sides ran from about $407K to $480K, and acreage north and west of town ran $961K to $1.20M.

I went through every Caldwell home that sold in the last 12 months, 1,457 sales in all, plus everything for sale today, and broke it down area by area. Here's what I found, in plain English.
The big picture: the median sold price was $424,990, or about $239 per square foot. Homes sold in a median of 30 days at 98.9% of their original asking price, but about six in ten sellers (62%) paid toward the buyer's closing costs, a median of $11,000. About four in ten sales were brand new, 576 in all, at a $446,945 median versus $399,000 for resales. 71% of homes sold were single level, and 38% sold for under $400K.
Downtown & Central ($350K median, 104 sales). Downtown, Indian Creek and the streets around it, out to Florida Ave. This is Caldwell's most affordable area: Historic Downtown's 1910s to 60s homes sold at a $294K median with no HOA, and Washington Heights at $355K. Oregon Commons sold new one-level homes near downtown for about $380K, also with no HOA, and Lennar's Jayhawk Creek sold new two-story homes at a $437K median, with 37 more for sale.
South, 10th Ave ($480K median, 113 sales). South of Linden between Kimball and Montana, with Caldwell schools. Late-'90s starter homes in West Valley Estates ($332K) and Silverbow ($340K) sit near newer communities: Hayden's Ferncroft at $380K, Lennar's Soterra at $527K with big plans including Next Gen suites, and Toll Brothers' single-level Pradera at $530K. Cumberland, with a pool, clubhouse and RV bays, sold at a $625K median.
Southeast, Homedale Rd ($410K median, 264 sales). Indiana Ave to Midway Rd, Ustick to Karcher, with Vallivue schools. 2000s neighborhoods like South Park ($360K), Windsor Creek ($371K) and Aspens ($400K) sit next to CBH's big new communities. Cedars was the biggest, with 73 sales at a $440K median, and Hubble's new Greenmont sold at $410K.
Karcher Rd, South Edge ($460K median, 243 sales). Along Karcher Rd (Hwy 55) toward Lake Lowell and wine country, and Caldwell's busiest new-home area. Toll Brothers' Passero Ridge sold 90 homes at a $488K median and has 52 for sale, the most in town. Lennar's Cirrus Pointe sold 81 at $480K, CBH's Guches Place sold new homes at $408K, and Sienna Hills, with Pioneer and custom homes and a pool, ran $595K.
Northeast, North of I-84 ($407K median, 346 sales). From the airport to Middleton Rd, mostly built since 2005 by CBH, Hubble, Hayden and Lennar, with Ridgevue High. Hayden's Shadow Glen sold 53 homes at a $405K median, CBH's new single-level Topaz Ranch West sold at $398K with 38 for sale, and Hubble's Mason Creek sold at $442K. Montecito Park was the most affordable at $355K, and Lennar's Mandalay Ranch, with a community pool, ran $488K.
North, Purple Sage ($1.20M median, 25 sales). Out Old Hwy 30 and Purple Sage Rd near Purple Sage Golf Course, with custom homes on acre lots and Middleton schools. Waterbrook Farms sold new homes on about 1-acre lots at a $979K median, Purple Sage Estates $1.08M and Oakridge Estates $1.36M. Albion Acres, on 2-acre lots, had Caldwell's top sale at $2.3 million.
West, Toward Greenleaf ($961K median, 20 sales). West along Ustick toward Greenleaf. Custom homes on the TimberStone Golf Course sold at a $1.02M median, and Northstar's custom single-level homes on acre lots at $1.23M. Tresidio's new Solstice is the more affordable option here at a $470K median, with 18 for sale.
For sale and building now: 580 homes are for sale or under contract, at a $439,995 median asking price, and 49% of them (287 homes) are new construction. CBH Homes built nearly four in ten new homes sold last year (221 of 576), followed by Lennar (116), Toll Brothers (108) and Hubble (44). CBH's Topaz Ranch West and Guches Place have brand-new homes listed in the $300s right now, and builders are offering rate buy-downs and closing-cost help.
Caldwell addresses can fall in three school districts: Caldwell School District serves downtown and the south side (Caldwell High), Vallivue covers the east (Vallivue and Ridgevue High), and the north acreage goes to Middleton.
I put all of this into a free 14-page Caldwell Neighborhood Guide with photos, maps, price ranges, lot sizes and who's building in each area. Download it free at brad.livinginidaho.com/caldwell-neighborhood-guide (instant PDF, no phone number needed), or text me at (208) 996-4872 and I'll send it over. Thinking of a move to Caldwell, let's connect.
Your situation is probably a little different
Text me the specifics and I'll tell you straight how I'd handle it.
Thinking about selling?
What is your Star home actually worth right now?
Not an automated guess off a website. A real opinion of value from someone who has walked these subdivisions, with the comparable sales that back it up.